This is NOT your practice life!

How To Face Daily Challenges and Harsh Realities To Find Inner Peace through Mental Mapping
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Test

The Rights of Gomoys

9/12/2017

0 Comments

 
You believe in personal freedom. But you also believe that others probably need some imposition of limitations on their freedom. You also believe in “rights.” But you know that not everyone deserves the same rights. Oh! Come on. You do so. Right to life? What about enemies, really serious enemies who harm you or your loved ones? You don’t hold any exceptions? Everyone’s equal at all times and in all places regardless of personal behavior, you argue. Okay. How did you come by that belief? Is there an innate goodness that underlies your thinking? What if someone thought the foundation of morality was evil?
 
In the second half of the eighteenth century first Danish and then British members of a Christian missionary group went to the Nicobar Islands to convert the native population. One missionary, the Rev. John Gottfried Haensel, wrote letters about the islands and Nicobar’s residents to the Rev. C. I. Latrobe.
 
Haensel made observations about the beliefs of the people he encountered there, noting in “Letter V” that “The natives of these islands are a free people, perfectly independent but have a captain in every village…Yet no one is bound to obey him, for all of them, male and female, consider themselves under no control whatever….”* Then Haensel addresses their “religion.”
 
            “They have not even a word in their language to express their idea of God. They use the word Knallen when they speak of Him, but it only signifies ‘above, on high’: for instance, they say, Knallen maade, ‘on the hill’; Knallen uniga, ‘on top of the tree’; Knallen gamalee, ‘on the surface of the sea’…this ‘unknown God’ is good…but wherein His goodness consists, they neither have, nor seem to wish to have, any understanding, nor ever trouble themselves about Him” (p. 51).
 
Haensel says that when his missionary group tried to convert them to Christian beliefs by telling them about a crucified savior who had sacrificed his life for their “sins,” “They observed that they could not believe that the sufferings of one man could atone for the sins of another…but they insisted that they were good by nature, and never did anything wrong…”(p. 53).
 
Of course, the mission of missionaries is to convince. Hearing that the islanders believed they never did anything wrong, Haensel related to them that the missionaries had witnessed murders and the abuse of corpses. He asked, “…was this a proof of their natural goodness?” Their response: “…you do not understand, those were people not fit to live, they were Gomoy, cannibals!” (p.51)
 
Let’s recap. Missionaries with western and Christian values visited an archipelago between the Bay of Bengal and the Andaman Sea, where they attempted to persuade people to think and act in ways alien to their culture. On the Nicobar Islands the missionaries found a different concept of God, a justification for murder, and a society where individuals believed in their own “goodness” and exercised freedom from authority.
 
Wait! For Westerners, it gets stranger. In Letter VI Haensel relates that the islanders believed that disease is the work of “the devil,” Eewee, a “wicked agent,” whom sorcerers, or Paters, control (p. 52). The sorcerers performed rituals akin to exorcisms on sick people. If an exorcism failed to cast out the Eewee, the sorcerer said the devil had possessed a local person, typically a person the sorcerer hated. You guessed it: Salem Witch Trial Time in the islands and death to the suspected possessed “witch.” Strangely, in a people that prided themselves on their personal independence and freedom from authority, the locals had no problem handing the power of life and death over the accused to sorcerers.
 
Eewee was the Creator, by the way, and that freed the islanders from personal moral responsibility. Their common expression was, “The Eewee did not make me perfect, or better” when they were accused of some atrocious crime (p. 53). Can’t blame someone who was created by a devil for doing devilish things, right? Personal responsibility for “sins” passes to Eewee in a belief system that was the antithesis of Christianity.
 
Does any of this make you pause to think about the meaning of “good,” “sin,” and “personal freedom”? Does a society that sees no value in the life of a Gomoy, that has no seeming sense of personal accountability for “sin,” and that looks nowhere for some supreme Goodness have a moral foundation?
 
Should a Gomoy have a right to life? Should an accusation of witchcraft that carries an unchallenged death sentence have moral weight? Where do you stand on personal responsibility?
 
Bring it forward to our time. Have you noted in the news the rioters dressed in black with black face masks attacking other people, supposedly because the other people are as unworthy of rights as Gomoys? Are the masked rioters incarnations of yesteryear’s Nicobar Paters?  Do they attempt to purge society of evil by violence they justify without having to take personal responsibility? Do we assume complete and unfettered freedom yet give to “sorcerers” control over certain lives?
 
Are we different from those nineteenth-century islanders? Of course, you are going to say “Yes, because we are ‘civilized’ and rational. And,” you continue, “we think everyone has inalienable rights, especially the right to life.” But don’t we find at least pockets of Nicobar Islanders giving over to anonymous people the power to hurt and kill in our own society? And don’t we also argue that personal freedom doesn’t count as a ground for personal responsibility in a world where society is as influential as Eewee? We’ve all heard the expression “victim of society” applied to evildoers. How do we respond?
 
Do we assume an underlying evil or an underlying good? The former eliminates personal responsibility; the latter demands it. Or should we assume that the world is fundamentally amoral and that all morality is simply a matter of culture with no absolutes and no inalienable rights? Now what are you going to do with those Gomoys? 
 
* Haensel, John Gottfried, Rev. Letters on the Nicobar Islands, Their Natural Productions, and the Manners, Customs, and Superstitions of the Natives: With an Account of an Attempt Made by the Church of the United Brethren To Convert Them to Christianity, Addressed by the Rev. John Gottfried Haensel (The Only surviving Missionary) to the Rev. C. I. Latrobe, London. Printed for the Editor, No. 10, Nevil’s Court, Fetter Lane, by W. McDowall, Pemberton Row. 1812. Online at http://www.gutenberg.org/files/26781/26781-h/26781-h.htm
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015

    Categories

    All
    000 Years Ago
    11:30 A.M.
    130
    19
    3d
    A Life Affluent
    All Joy Turneth To Sorrow
    Aluminum
    Amblyopia
    And Minarets
    And Then Philippa Spoke Up
    Area 51 V. Photo 51
    Area Of Influence
    Are You Listening?
    As Carmen Sings
    As Useless As Yesterday's Newspaper
    As You Map Today
    A Treasure Of Great Price
    A Vice In Her Goodness
    Bananas
    Before You Sling Dirt
    Blue Photons Do The Job
    Bottom Of The Ninth
    Bouncing
    Brackets Of Life
    But
    But Uncreative
    Ca)2Al4Si14O36·15H2O: When The Fortress Walls Are The Enemy
    Can You Pick Up A Cast Die?
    Cartography Of Control
    Charge Of The Light Brigade
    Cloister Earth
    Compasses
    Crater Lake
    Crystalline Vs Amorphous
    Crystal Unclear
    Density
    Dido As Diode
    Disappointment
    Does Place Exert An Emotional Force?
    Do Fish Fear Fire?
    Don't Go Up There
    Double-take
    Down By A Run
    Dust
    Endless Is The Good
    Epic Fail
    Eros And Canon In D Headbanger
    Euclid
    Euthyphro Is Alive And Well
    Faethm
    Faith
    Fast Brain
    Fetch
    Fido's Fangs
    Fly Ball
    For Some It’s Morning In Mourning
    For The Skin Of An Elephant
    Fortunately
    Fracking Emotions
    Fractions
    Fused Sentences
    Future Perfect
    Geographic Caricature And Opportunity
    Glacier
    Gold For Salt?
    Great
    Gutsy Or Dumb?
    Here There Be Blogs
    Human Florigen
    If Galileo Were A Psychologist
    If I Were A Child
    I Map
    In Search Of Philosopher's Stones
    In Search Of The Human Ponor
    I Repeat
    Is It Just Me?
    Ithaca Is Yours
    It's All Doom And Gloom
    It's Always A Battle
    It's Always All About You
    It’s A Messy Organization
    It’s A Palliative World
    It Takes A Simple Mindset
    Just Because It's True
    Just For You
    K2
    Keep It Simple
    King For A Day
    Laki
    Life On Mars
    Lines On Canvas
    Little Girl In The Fog
    Living Fossils
    Longshore Transport
    Lost Teeth
    Magma
    Majestic
    Make And Break
    Maslow’s Five And My Three
    Meditation Upon No Red Balloon
    Message In A Throttle
    Meteor Shower
    Minerals
    Mono-anthropism
    Monsters In The Cloud Of Memory
    Moral Indemnity
    More Of The Same
    Movie Award
    Moving Motionless
    (Na2
    Never Despair
    New Year's Eve
    Not Real
    Not Your Cup Of Tea?
    Now What Are You Doing?
    Of Consciousness And Iconoclasts
    Of Earworms And Spicy Foods
    Of Polygons And Circles
    Of Roof Collapses
    Oh
    Omen
    One Click
    Outsiders On The Inside
    Pain Free
    Passion Blew The Gale
    Perfect Philosophy
    Place
    Points Of Departure
    Politically Correct Tale
    Polylocation
    Pressure Point
    Prison
    Pro Tanto World
    Refresh
    Regret Over Missing An Un-hittable Target
    Relentless
    REPOSTED BLOG: √2
    REPOSTED BLOG: Algebraic Proof You’re Always Right
    REPOSTED BLOG: Are You Diana?
    REPOSTED BLOG: Assimilating Values
    REPOSTED BLOG: Bamboo
    REPOSTED BLOG: Discoverers And Creators
    REPOSTED BLOG: Emotional Relief
    REPOSTED BLOG: Feeling Unappreciated?
    REPOSTED BLOG: Missing Anxiety By A Millimeter Or Infinity
    REPOSTED BLOG: Palimpsest
    REPOSTED BLOG: Picture This
    REPOSTED BLOG: Proximity And Empathy
    Reposted Blog: Sacred Ground
    REPOSTED BLOG: Sedit Qui Timuit Ne Non Succederet
    REPOSTED BLOG: Sic Transit Gloria Mundi
    REPOSTED BLOG: Sponges And Brains
    REPOSTED BLOG: The Fiddler In The Pantheon
    REPOSTED BLOG: The Junk Drawer
    REPOSTED BLOG: The Pattern Axiom
    REPOSTED IN LIGHT OF THE RECENT OREGON ATTACK: Special By Virtue Of Being Here
    REPOSTED: Place
    River Or Lake?
    Scales
    Self-driving Miss Daisy
    Seven Centimeters Per Year
    Shouting At The Crossroads
    Sikharas
    Similar Differences And Different Similarities
    Simple Tune
    Slow Mind
    Stages
    Steeples
    Stupas
    “Such Is Life”
    Sutra Addiction
    Swivel Chair
    Take Me To Your Leader
    Tats
    Tautological Redundancy
    Template
    The
    The Baby And The Centenarian
    The Claw Of Arakaou
    The Embodiment Of Place
    The Emperor And The Unwanted Gift
    The Final Frontier
    The Flow
    The Folly Of Presuming Victory
    The Hand Of God
    The Inostensible Source
    The Lions Clawee9b37e566
    Then Eyjafjallajökull
    The Proprioceptive One Survives
    The Qualifier
    The Scapegoat In The Mirror
    The Slowest Waterfall
    The Transformer On Bourbon Street
    The Unsinkable Boat
    The Workable Ponzi Scheme
    They'll Be Fine; Don't Worry
    Through The Unopened Door
    Time
    Toddler
    To Drink Or Not To Drink
    Trust
    Two On
    Two Out
    Umbrella
    Unconformities
    Unknown
    Vector Bundle
    Warning Track Power
    Wattle And Daub
    Waxing And Waning
    Wealth And Dependence
    What Does It Mean?
    What Do You Really Want?
    What Kind Of Character Are You?
    What Microcosm Today?
    What Would Alexander Do7996772102
    Where’s Jacob Henry When You Need Him?
    Where There Is No Geography
    Window
    Wish I Had Taken Guitar Lessons
    Wonderful Things
    Wonders
    Word Pass
    Yes
    You
    You Could
    Your Personal Kiribati

    RSS Feed


Web Hosting by iPage