I know, I know. This website’s entry page declares that place is primary and time is secondary, and to prove that statement asks you to think of ten minutes ago without any spatial or material reference. The proposition of the priority of space or place suggests that in the context of our current understanding, time did not exist before there was a universe, which is the place for its unfolding--progressing and passing if those are more appropriate terms. (Let’s discount for the sake of this argument that only the present exists; thus negating through an “eternal present” any unfolding, passing, or progressing. But, I’ll finish with that thought. So, time’s “arrow,” as physicists like to say, is a one-way flight for us, and it always occurs in our realm of daily living among things that occupy space, that is, in a place)
Space-time seems to belie my claim about space, of course; Einstein’s understanding implies that space AND time had a conjoined birth, making my argument weak in the minds of scientists that accept the Big Bang explanation of the Big How of existence. But since time could not pass BEFORE THE UNIVERSE, then WHERE THE UNIVERSE originated takes precedence, and not only do I know the place where the universe originated, but I can also point it out to you. Rather, you can point it out to yourself just by looking in the mirror. Yes, you are the center of the universe and the site of the Big Bang because all that is was together in the singularity. Not to burst your significance bubble, but I am also that site as is everyone and everything else.
It’s also significant for my argument that time varies under the influence of velocity and matter (gravity), both of which occur in “place,” a fact that weakens the argument that time and space are “equals,” the latter serving as the context or matrix for the former. By any measure, we know time by material existence, by the movement of objects in space—everything, after all, is moving relative to something else, even a binge-watching couch potato sits on a couch on a spinning planet orbiting a sun that orbits the galaxy that moves through the universe. Because that couch potato still ostensibly moves more through time than through space from his and our perspective, he ages, we say, without movement.
I’ll continue to hold space’s priority on the basis that we cannot think of a personal “when” without a personal “where.” Place is, if not the cause, certainly the circumstance or the environment under or in which we pass time, and it is a significant control on us: I’ll whisper in a sanctuary but shout in a mosh pit regardless of time. I’ll use extreme caution in a minefield and practically no caution in a La-Z-Boy recliner, save that of not spilling my drink on my torso. Yes, place determines much for me regardless of, for example, my age, my time, and the clock hands turning, the quartz crystals vibrating in a watch, or that atomic clock that “keeps precise time.”
I cannot, in spite of my assumption about the priority of place—and thus, space—over time, escape that time is what I often use to locate myself. True, I know location by dividing space, using, for example, those grid lines we know as longitude and latitude or those segments of Earth’s orbit we call the seasons. In an era of navigation systems, Einstein’s spacetime dictates a consideration of Relativity for accuracy, those satellites operating in a different gravitational frame at a different speed from the earthbound person seeking a previously unvisited address. Clocks onboard those satellites must be adjusted for the difference in time’s passing; otherwise, navigation systems in our cars would be useless, or at least, misleading because of accumulating inaccuracies, so strong is the effect of Einstein’s Relativity.
NASA uses earthbound atomic clocks to know the whereabouts of distant spacecraft. And now it is developing a deep space atomic clock that would eliminate the delay in navigation caused by increasing distance and acceleration. After all, radio/light waves have a finite speed. To know about a spacecraft’s location, NASA currently sends a signal from Earth, awaits its return, and then sends another signal to the spacecraft. Timing the trips to and from yield a location. Trips like that in our big Solar System take minutes to hours at the speed of light. An onboard atomic clock synchronized with an earthbound twin would cut some of the time by eliminating at least one leg of the message’s journey.
So, what’s all this have to do with you, especially if you’re not involved in spacecraft location during space travel? On the simplest level, we might think of a wristwatch as a personal portable atomic clock. All those smart watches give us that kind of accuracy. So, your friend and you want to meet in a certain space simultaneously. Although you don’t need atomic-clock accuracy, you meet as you said you would thanks to those watches you carry. On a more complex level, we might think of a “distance” in time from an important event, like leaving the home of your youth to live on your own. Do you think of time’s passage in spatial terms? “That was in the distant past.” History books’ timelines give us the same kind of metaphor. Do you think of your life’s events as being either closer to or farther from your present? Think, now, of time’s passing. Do you see a clock, a pendulum, the rising and setting sun, or the progressively downward movement of eye bags and wrinkled skin? All matter and space, right? You frame time in spatial metaphors. You locate in place by time and vice versa. You even carry your own biological clock.
But there is one version of the clock we carry that doesn’t record any change regardless of our movement through space, that is, from place to place. That’s the Grudge Clock. Many people carry such clocks with them, making the interaction that precipitated the “grudge” occur always in an eternal present. They locate themselves on the basis of that grudge clock. Everywhere they go, regardless of time, they can hear the ticking of the grudge that locates them in a specific place at a specific time, and makes everything relative to that event, much like a spacecraft’s leaving Earth and being located by those homebound atomic clocks that send out and receive signals. Grudge clocks, unlike regular clocks of any kind, are unaffected by movements in and away from neighborhoods, cities, states, or even countries. I suppose even astronauts might identify where they are in life or space by a grudge clock.
So, yes, time is important, and yes, it apparently stops in an eternal present, an eternal grudge. Are you locating yourself on the basis of a Grudge Clock? If you are, you might consider that the person or group against which you hold the grudge isn’t wearing the same watch, isn’t locating on the basis of the same time, and isn’t necessarily even aware of the beginning of the time you use for locating yourself, of identifying your whereabouts in the Cosmos. And as for place? Well the place where your significant grudge-time began might not even be the same as it once was. Einstein’s Relativity explains one kind of relationship between space or place and time; your personal relativity explains the human analog.